Blog›Social Media›The Impact of Creatives in Social Media Advertising
Social Media

The Impact of Creatives in Social Media Advertising

Optimising your social media ads takes striking visuals, a clear message and regular testing. Learn how to build effective creatives with our checklist of tips for creatives that perform.

CarlaCarla10 February 20258 min read

Making creatives that perform on social media follows a simple recipe (that’s a joke): a good campaign setup, a good message, good tracking, the right format, tons of tests and above all a good visual, also called the creative. But how much does the visual matter among all these factors?

Whether it’s a static image, a video or a carousel, visuals are essential to stop users from scrolling.

By using well-thought-out visuals and adapting them to each platform and, above all, to the expected formats, you can prompt users to act. Well-designed visuals also strengthen brand awareness and can help build consumer trust.

In this article, discover best practices and tips to maximise the impact of your creatives and stand out in your social ads.

Why creatives matter in social ads

As you’ve surely noticed, users’ attention is harder and harder to capture, which is why visuals play a leading role in the success of your social media campaigns. Visuals communicate messages instantly and effectively. They convey your brand identity and catch consumers’ eye in an oversaturated feed.

Social media users are exposed to a flood of content in a fraction of a second, so the brain sorts what seems relevant from what doesn’t. That’s why it pays to invest in quality visuals that not only reflect the brand’s message but are also tailored to the target audience.

Remember that creatives help build an emotional connection with consumers. They can strengthen brand attachment by including visual elements that resonate with users’ values, increasing long-term loyalty and engagement.

How do you make good creatives?

Here is your checklist of what a good creative needs. First of all, it is crucial to know your target audience. Understanding users’ preferences, behaviours and expectations lets you create visuals that speak to them. Once that groundwork is done, here is your checklist:

Does it grab attention immediately?

  • The creative is striking and catches the eye from the very first second (test it rather than just assume). For this, you can follow our guide to making your creatives easily with Canva.
  • Colours and contrast are optimised to stand out in the feed.
  • The format suits the social network (post, story, carousel, reel…).

Is the message clear and punchy?

  • The hook is short (5–7 words max) and highlights the value proposition.
  • The text is readable, even on mobile (neither too small nor too long).
  • The message is easy to understand.

Is there an effective call to action (CTA)?

  • The CTA is clearly visible (“Buy now”, “Discover”, “Download”).
  • It drives action with a sense of urgency (“Limited offer”, “Last days!”).

Is it consistent with the brand identity?

  • Colours and fonts follow the brand guidelines.
  • The tone and style match the target audience.
  • Branding is clearly present (visible logo and brand name).

Is it optimised for social platforms?

  • The format meets each network’s specifications (1:1, 4:5, 9:16…). I recommend reading our article on the stories format.
  • The video (if used) grabs attention from the first second with a hook.
  • The file is light and well compressed for fast loading.

Is there social proof or a reassurance element?

  • A customer review or a credible statistic is included.
  • A label or certification reinforces trust (where relevant).

Have you tested and measured its effectiveness?

  • An A/B test has been launched with different versions.
  • Performance is tracked (CTR, engagement, conversions).
  • Underperforming elements are adjusted based on the results.

If every box is ticked, your creative is ready to perform!

How should I test my creatives?

As we discussed in the podcast episode on the impact of visuals in paid social with Thibault, A/B testing is essential to make sure your creatives work. It lets you compare several versions of an ad to identify the one that drives the most engagement, clicks or conversions.

A good A/B test focuses on one element at a time so you can pinpoint what influences your ad’s performance. Testable elements obviously include the creative (image vs video, colours, layout), the copy (hook, message length, tone), the call to action (“Buy now” vs “Discover the offer”), the target audience (different age or interest segments) and the format (carousel vs single image, short vs long video).

For example, if you test an image against a video, make sure the copy and CTA stay identical to isolate the impact of the format on performance. How long the test runs depends largely on your budget and on how many clicks or conversions that budget can generate.

And it never really ends: once your test is over and you’ve identified the results, optimise and start again.

Trust Donutz with your social ads campaigns!

As you can see, visuals play a central role in capturing attention and getting your message across. But that’s not all! You need to factor in all the other parameters I mentioned: setup, message, targeting and testing. That’s exactly the kind of project Donutz supports, with clients across Europe and beyond. With our senior experts, we act as a true partner in the success of your social ads.

At Donutz, we do much more than run campaigns. We turn your clicks into loyal customers! Maximise your online visibility and reach your growth targets on Facebook, Instagram, TikTok and every other social network.

Shall we talk about your needs?


Ready to grow your digital marketing?

Get a free audit from our experts — no commitment.

Get your free plan →